At Ellen’s Stardust Diner in Times Square, tuna melts are delivered between ballads
Keith White has his hands full. Table thirteen needs ketchup, and table four’s French fries are growing cold on the pass. He’s just been sat a ten-top: a middle school choir from Kansas City thirsty for Shirley Temples, their OMNY cards and Aladdin Playbills littering the floor. He whips into the kitchen and fires a reorder of waffle-cut, then drops off a fresh bottle of Heinz. The Shirley Temples will have to wait. He’s got a song to sing.
As a server at Ellen’s Stardust Diner in Times Square, working the floor is its own juggling act. “We have people ask for more ranch while you’re singing,” says White, a singing server at the restaurant, who balances customer service interactions with chart-topping hits. His favorite songs to perform are by Tears for Fears and Prince.
“I don’t really sing any musical theatre right now, but maybe that’s my role,” he admits. “The dads that didn’t want to come to the showtunes restaurant? I’m their guy.”
Ellen’s Stardust Diner was opened in 1987 by Ellen Hart Sturm, a 1959 titleholder of “Miss Subways,” a New York City–based beauty pageant in which photos of the contestants plastered the walls of every train car from Inwood to Brighton Beach. The restaurant epitomizes her victorious year: neon and poodle skirts, sock hops and milkshakes. It’s 1950s through an anachronistic lens: the Grease of greasy spoons. From 7 a.m. to midnight, servers dash between booths and lunge up the stairs with a tuna melt in one hand and a microphone in the other. The restaurant opens with a full breakfast menu, and waiters start singing by the time the first cup of coffee is poured. On my visit, the confetti cannons launched at 8:34 a.m.
“We’ll ease into the day a little bit,” says Sean Doherty, an actor who began serving at Ellen’s a year ago. “We don’t want to start screaming ‘Defying Gravity’ at you first thing in the morning.”
Doherty starts the morning shifts with “Younger Than Springtime” from South Pacific, a classic ballad that acts as a warm-up and a way to gauge his vocal range that day. After that, he might need another jazz standard before jumping into the sustained high A that completes “Santa Fe” from Newsies.
“When I was younger, I’d go to work and be like, ‘Let’s hit it running,’” says Bianca DiSarro, a server and emcee who has worked at Ellen’s on and off between performing gigs since 2013.

Bianca DiSarro curates the lineup as emcee.
“Now, every morning I have a good warm-up to make sure my voice is going to be healthy throughout the day: blowing bubbles, nebulizing, and seeing where I’m at,” explains DiSarro. She starts the morning with “Landslide” by Fleetwood Mac.
As emcee, DiSarro introduces the next singer and the song they’ll be performing based on a run of show on a computer next to the bar. She keeps tabs on birthday celebrations and special song requests from musical theatre enthusiasts who are visiting the restaurant for the first time.
The songs themselves are chosen at the singer’s discretion. A lyrical soprano working on her contemporary belt for an upcoming audition might want to take the material for a test drive, adding the Legally Blonde Act 1 finale “So Much Better” to her setlist. A classical baritone might finish off his shift with a tried-and-true standard he’s known for years, like “Soliloquy” from Carousel. Anything (excluding curse words) is fair game. While some emcees plan the setlist from the start, DiSarro prefers to leave some wiggle room.
“I always go on the vibe of the room and fly by the seat of my pants,” she says. A pre-matinee lunch crowd abuzz with families and small children goes crazy for “Let It Go,” while crooner classics like “My Way” and “New York, New York” resonate with booths full of non-English-speaking tourists. DiSarro’s first few years as a singing server prepared her to read the crowd, and when the emcee position was created over a decade ago, she jumped at the opportunity to curate the setlist, even though the pay is about the same.
DiSarro also looks out for the waitstaff. If one server just got sat an eight-top, she’ll bump their performance of the Dreamgirls hit “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” to later in the set. Communicating these changes can be a challenge when the singers themselves are hearing the lineup in the moment. Often, it’s as simple as a distinct look or a clear hand gesture from server to emcee that indicates they need more time to refill a table’s Diet Cokes before hopping on the mic. No matter—DiSarro’s already read their minds.

A catwalk between diner booths acts as center-stage.
“I can see if one of my coworkers just got slammed and if singing a song is going to put them in the weeds,” explains DiSarro. “I know what it’s like. If I feel like everyone is that way, I’ll jump in and sing a song.”
The emcee plays an integral part in the balance between excellent customer service and Broadway-caliber performances. One shouldn’t suffer for the other, and at times, that balance can feel overwhelming for both emcee and server. During some shifts, Doherty wears special earplugs that block out certain decibels, a reprieve from the endless overtures and bass-thumping interludes blaring from the overhead speakers. White uses his songs as an opportunity to disengage from the demands of the diners, a mid-shift palate cleanse. For DiSarro, it takes a dose of apathy.
“There’s no such thing as a cheeseburger emergency,” she says. “Everyone will get fed, and everyone will hear me sing.”
During peak holiday hours, a line of guests waiting for tables snakes down 51st Street toward 7th Avenue, sometimes well before the restaurant’s 7 a.m. opening time. Waits average over an hour. The tater tots are secondary—most visitors come for the show. Still, the singing can be a surprise to some guests.
“There are people who are just coming to eat. They expect the service to be instant, like it would be at any other restaurant,” says DiSarro.
Regardless of their expectations, the element of song introduces a vulnerability that is typically absent from the restaurant archetype. When a server isn’t just a server, the relationship between server and diner transcends the transactional.
“You finish singing, and it’s like you’re a magician or something. All of a sudden, they’re in awe of you,” notices White, who recognizes that diners typically have a passive relationship with their servers. For Doherty, the music offers a chance to distract challenging tables.
“It’s something you don’t get at other restaurants. They’ll see you as a means to an end. But if something goes wrong with the meal, you can ask them their favorite song and make sure someone sings it,” he says.

The menu at Ellen’s features diner classics: pancakes, waffle fries, and piled-high burgers.
The opportunity to work as a server at Ellen’s Stardust Diner is extremely competitive, and as a tourist favorite in the heart of Times Square, so is the pay. The list of applicants is long. To begin with, everyone is required to have at least two years of high-volume New York City serving experience. From there, the audition process is not dissimilar to a Broadway audition. Applicants perform two contrasting songs for a panel that decides whether they move on to the next round of callbacks, often for multiple rounds. Many who have passed the audition and callback process wait months for a chance to make it on the floor. More than 100 servers are currently on the roster at Ellen’s, with 15 servers on the floor at any given time.
The tough competition is also characteristic of Gayle’s Broadway Rose, a similar dining establishment that operates in the evenings at the restaurant Friedman’s, also in Times Square. In recent years, this competition has only increased as the social media presence of both Ellen’s Stardust Diner and Gayle’s Broadway Rose has exploded. Videos of the singing servers posted to the restaurants’ social media accounts garner millions of views, and both restaurants’ accounts boast hundreds of thousands of followers. It’s priceless visibility and valuable content for performers who strive to work consistently on bigger stages.
“We have QR codes throughout the restaurant so people can look you up and see who you are and what you do,” explains CR Sapp, a singing server at Gayle’s Broadway Rose. “We’re in the heart of Times Square, so it’s like you’re performing on Broadway.”
Mikako Martin, an actor who began working as a server at Gayle’s Broadway Rose earlier this summer, sees this accessibility as mutually beneficial for both server and diner: while out-of-work actors get a highly visible performing gig in the heart of the Theater District, theatergoers who can’t necessarily afford front-row tickets to The Lost Boys or The Great Gatsby get up close and personal with Broadway-level talent.
“It’s so accessible and so personal,” says Martin. “They’re stoked that someone is singing to them and performing just for them.”
Doherty agrees. “One of my favorite things is when you get a table and there is an 18-year-old with their family, and they’ve just been accepted to the University of Michigan for musical theatre,” he says. “That’s how we all started. It helps people who might think, ‘A career in this might not be the best idea.’ But it is possible.” For young hopefuls, it’s a window into the reality of the hustle, another way to define the term “working actor.”

A singing server works the crowd.
At Ellen’s, servers’ voice lessons and dance classes are funded in part by a donation bucket that is passed around the restaurant every hour. These cash donations go straight to funding these extra costs. It’s a lifeline for the servers.
“It’s a grind. You do want to get better. The talent pool is always growing, and the only way to stay competitive is to be in class,” says White. “It really does work.”
The proof is tenfold. The alumni base of Ellen’s Stardust Diner servers that are currently performing in Broadway or off-Broadway shows is expansive. Some, like Titaníque creator Marla Mindelle, have gone on to become Tony nominees.
After closing, when the last guests have left the restaurant, leaving in their wake straw wrappers and Subway maps among the ketchup stains and confetti, the servers hang up their aprons and go home. More often than not, their night is hardly over. At home, 8-by-10 headshots are stapled to crisp résumés, and pages of freshly printed sheet music are slid into non-glare sheet protectors, ready for the next morning’s audition. After a long night, they’ve got another song to sing.